The first time I voted, I cast my No1 to a random PN candidate and my No2 to AD.
I didn’t like the PN much but considered them as a lesser evil. Then I realized that I should give my No 1 to support the part and principles I believed in because at the end of the day, the world will not end if either the PN and PL is in government and my no 1 vote gives a very strong message – a message against blind tribalism. After my first election I am proud to have given my number 1 vote to AD each and every election with no regrets.
By the time, my interest in politics grew, and the more I came to know about Alternattiva Demokratika, the more I liked them. To the extent of eventually joining the party, and will be contesting Local Elections on Mosta next March.
If one had to ask me what I find different in AD, I will point mainly towards two things, which I will call Freedom and Direction.
Freedom
No one in AD has his hands tied. It doesn’t accept donations from people/companies it may have a conflict of interest with and no one in the party has any personal interest that may jeopardise his position in politics, be it with a construction magnate, a contractor or a North African tyrant.
In other words we are free. We say what we believe is right because no one is pulling our strings.
Direction
In modern Europe, one hears about political ideology much less than before. In a way this is good. Fewer people are fossilized into ideologies of both left and right and many try to avoid any of the two extremes. This is partly due to the atrocities committed by both sides in our not-so-distant history.
However, in many European countries ideology has died completely, to the extent that democracy is not undermined by tyrants who oppose free and fair elections but by the fact voting for a party or another doesn’t actually make any difference.
This can’t be more true than in Malta where I describe both parties’ ideology as a “mad rush to where they think the votes are”
They use the term “rainbow party” as if it is some kind of compliment! In MEP elections, you could have voted for hunters advocate Perici Calascione or environmentalist Alan Deidun, both contesting on the same party ticket (PN). On the other hand, in the same PL opposition, you have ultra-conservative Adrian Vassallo but can still vote for a liberal like Evarist Bartolo. So on and so forth.
I don’t consider that as a rainbow but a complete mess.
Needless to say, we in AD do not always agree on everything. That would be against human nature. We do have our squabbles. However these are usually sorted out in a short time and without any resentment, not only because we mean well but also because unlike in the examples mentioned above, we don’t have people who are diametrically opposed to each other.
In short I think of Green ideology as left of center, liberal and one that puts a lot of weight on ecological issues. That said, this is not (and should not be) shrouded in dogma and a refusal to make a compromise, but a clear direction.
We do not promise a quick-fix for Malta’s problems like populist parties. Anyone who proposes that is either lying or hallucinating.
However, we do offer something different. A change that while I’m sure there are people who honestly mean it in both PN and PL, for the reasons mentioned above, can never deliver it.
11 January, 2012 at 11:10 pm
Excellent post Robert. Indeed, the irony of the so called progressive party fielding men like Vassallo, cringeworthy.
11 January, 2012 at 11:51 pm
The big question is, what is the change that AD is proposing?
(And I will not ask how it is going to be delivered.)
12 January, 2012 at 12:01 am
I think you will best find your answers and our stand on different issues from our website
http://www.alternattiva.org/
You can also be updated regularly by joining this yahoo group
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/alternattiva/
12 January, 2012 at 1:07 am
I looked over AD’s website.
I’ll rephrase the question:
Where is AD’s plan for change?
(Certainly not on the website.)
Voters are neither philosophers nor clairvoyants. They are taxpayers who feel the pinch of what they perceive to be the high cost of living. They have their own way of assessing who is best to govern; or, in better Maltese, they are born either NP or PL. One will be forgiven to conclude that it is genetic.
AD has been around for over 20 years. By now, it should be crystal clear that, the Maltese political milieux is toxic beyond redemption, leaving no room for a third party.
If AD were to ever, in my lifetime, attain the status of a major party, that is, either gain the government or the Opposition, then I will stop being a Humanist and start believing in miracles.
I wish you luck in the coming election.
12 January, 2012 at 9:04 am
Cjohn, on the Website there are our concrete proposals. Soon there will be the manifesto.
If you want to ask about a specific issue, do so, but I can’t reply to generalized questions.
Regarding AD being round for 20 years, and electing people only in Local Councils, it doesn’t deter me from believing it won’t remain so.
The problem is not our ideology, which has a lot of support but the PNPL mentality, and I believe that will change.
Especially for 2 reasons:
1) Privatization. While I’m not in agreement to all this privatization that’s going on, a side effect is that “il-ministru ma jistax jibqa jsiblek job”. Unfortunately many people feel loyal to a party or another for similar reasons.
2) New media. When you are a small party with lacking finances,it’s hard to spread the message only through mainstream media. New media on the other hand is affordable and not controlled by any party.
I’m not saying it would be easy, far from that. We have a struggle. But I do have a lot of faith.
I also believe that if AD elects one candidate in Parliament, it would elect much more the following elections.
12 January, 2012 at 9:36 am
If someone votes for a party just because it is a ‘major party’ then we are really in a sad state…
The manifestos are on the website and other sites such as http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Alternattiva
There are more than enough proposals and plans… actually it is the other way round we never see any ‘plans’ from the other parties. Actually in 2008 we saw a 100 project ‘plan’ for the grand harbour area…and now it’s clear that it was just a nice exhibition with pretty picture because nothing came of it! As for Labour, hello? Anybody home?